• Search Research Projects
  • Search Researchers
  • How to Use
  1. Back to previous page

An Ethical Study on Autonomy and Paternalism in Preventive Medicine

Research Project

Project/Area Number 16520004
Research Category

Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (C)

Allocation TypeSingle-year Grants
Section一般
Research Field Philosophy/Ethics
Research InstitutionGunma University

Principal Investigator

HATTORI Kenji  GUNMA UNIVERSITY, Graduate School of Medicine, Professor, 大学院・医学系研究科, 教授 (90312884)

Project Period (FY) 2004 – 2005
Project Status Completed (Fiscal Year 2005)
Budget Amount *help
¥2,000,000 (Direct Cost: ¥2,000,000)
Fiscal Year 2005: ¥900,000 (Direct Cost: ¥900,000)
Fiscal Year 2004: ¥1,100,000 (Direct Cost: ¥1,100,000)
KeywordsPREVENTIVE MEDICINE / HEALTH / AUTONOMY / PATERNALISM / OBLIGATION
Research Abstract

Recently the Health Promotion Law, which prescribes that all people have a duty to administrate their own health, has been enforced in Japan, whereby the life expectancy at birth for females is over 82 years. This paper is intended as a critical investigation of widespread discourses on the obligation to achieve good health for the people's own sake. In the beginning, we review the evolution of classical public health to the new public health movement. While classical public health addressed the improvement of the environment such as installing sewerage systems for infection prevention, the new public health movement since the mid 1970s has largely been concerned with our lifestyles. With some epidemiological surveys, both researchers and policy makers reached agreement on the tenet that reforming 'unhealthy' lifestyles is more effective and economical than curative health care practices. Thus, they insist that people have an obligation to promote their own health and prevent disease by self-discipline, and that medical intervention in people's lifestyle is justified. Here we outline the essential features of today's discourse on the duty to promote health as follows : healthism, a quasi-religious and moral characteristic of modern medicine, giving extraordinary meaning to diseases and illnesses by metaphors, the medicalization of our everyday life, and an excessive emphasis on personal responsibility for disease or illness as rhetoric to justify cutbacks in required health and social programs. As will be seen, we examine these claims of preventive medicine in detail. In conclusion, we cannot accept the idea of the obligation to promote health for people. On the contrary, it rather seems that the government is obliged to preserve the environment, to assure daily commodities' safety such as food, water, housing and so forth, and to improve health care services without paternalistic coercion.

Report

(3 results)
  • 2005 Annual Research Report   Final Research Report Summary
  • 2004 Annual Research Report
  • Research Products

    (5 results)

All 2006 2004

All Journal Article (4 results) Book (1 results)

  • [Journal Article] 健康を増進する義務2006

    • Author(s)
      服部健司
    • Journal Title

      生命倫理 17(印刷中)

    • NAID

      110006858345

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Related Report
      2005 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] A duty to promote health and prevent disease2006

    • Author(s)
      Hattori, Kenji
    • Journal Title

      Journal of Japan Association for Bioethics 17(in press)

    • NAID

      110006858345

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
    • Related Report
      2005 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] 多様な健康像の定式化の果てに2004

    • Author(s)
      服部健司
    • Journal Title

      医学哲学医学倫理 22号

      Pages: 155-160

    • Related Report
      2004 Annual Research Report
  • [Journal Article] 健康をめぐる反哲学的考察2004

    • Author(s)
      服部健司
    • Journal Title

      バイオエシックスの展望(東信堂)

      Pages: 209-235

    • Related Report
      2004 Annual Research Report
  • [Book] 医療倫理学のABC2004

    • Author(s)
      服部健司, 伊東隆雄
    • Total Pages
      279
    • Publisher
      メヂカルフレンド社
    • Related Report
      2004 Annual Research Report

URL: 

Published: 2004-04-01   Modified: 2016-04-21  

Information User Guide FAQ News Terms of Use Attribution of KAKENHI

Powered by NII kakenhi