• Search Research Projects
  • Search Researchers
  • How to Use
  1. Back to previous page

High-order reward punishment systems solves social dilemmas

Research Project

Project/Area Number 16H03120
Research Category

Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (B)

Allocation TypeSingle-year Grants
Section一般
Research Field Social systems engineering/Safety system
Research InstitutionThe University of Tokyo

Principal Investigator

Toriumi Fujio  東京大学, 大学院工学系研究科(工学部), 准教授 (30377775)

Co-Investigator(Kenkyū-buntansha) 秋山 英三  筑波大学, システム情報系, 教授 (40317300)
岡田 勇  創価大学, 経営学部, 准教授 (60323888)
山本 仁志  立正大学, 経営学部, 教授 (70328574)
Project Period (FY) 2016-04-01 – 2019-03-31
Project Status Completed (Fiscal Year 2018)
Budget Amount *help
¥16,900,000 (Direct Cost: ¥13,000,000、Indirect Cost: ¥3,900,000)
Fiscal Year 2018: ¥4,420,000 (Direct Cost: ¥3,400,000、Indirect Cost: ¥1,020,000)
Fiscal Year 2017: ¥5,590,000 (Direct Cost: ¥4,300,000、Indirect Cost: ¥1,290,000)
Fiscal Year 2016: ¥6,890,000 (Direct Cost: ¥5,300,000、Indirect Cost: ¥1,590,000)
Keywords社会的ジレンマ / 公共財ゲーム / マルチエージェントシミュレーション / 被験者実験 / 高次報酬懲罰系 / ソーシャルメディア / 社会システム / 計算社会科学
Outline of Final Research Achievements

We developed a theoretical approach of private assessment for analyzing social dilemmas in higher-order reward and punishment systems. We also clarified that a cooperative society would emerge when players' actions of second-order rewards were visualized even if there is no linkage between first-order and second-order rewards. This result is consistent with the results of our experiments which show that beliefs on sanctioning behaviors by the others have a positive influence on players' cooperative behaviors. Moreover, our experiment shows that the second-order punishment maintains higher cooperation than the first-order punishment.

Academic Significance and Societal Importance of the Research Achievements

高次報酬懲罰系における社会的ジレンマについて,理論,実験,シミュレーションの3点からアプローチし,社会的ジレンマの性質およびその解消法について明らかにできた.
本研究結果は社会的ジレンマが存在する社会システムの構築の際に,その設計に寄与すると考えられる.たとえば,公共財としての知識共有システムの利用促進などへの応用が期待される.

Report

(4 results)
  • 2018 Annual Research Report   Final Research Report ( PDF )
  • 2017 Annual Research Report
  • 2016 Annual Research Report
  • Research Products

    (51 results)

All 2019 2018 2017 2016

All Journal Article (16 results) (of which Int'l Joint Research: 6 results,  Peer Reviewed: 12 results,  Open Access: 12 results,  Acknowledgement Compliant: 1 results) Presentation (32 results) (of which Int'l Joint Research: 17 results,  Invited: 2 results) Funded Workshop (3 results)

  • [Journal Article] 特集「道徳判断の自動化をめぐる問題:規範の選択と協力の進化」にあたって2019

    • Author(s)
      岡田勇
    • Journal Title

      人工知能学会誌

      Volume: 34 Pages: 122-124

    • NAID

      130007917564

    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
  • [Journal Article] 進化的機械倫理のあらまし2019

    • Author(s)
      Han TA, Luis MP, 岡田勇
    • Journal Title

      人工知能学会誌

      Volume: 34 Pages: 152-159

    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
    • Int'l Joint Research
  • [Journal Article] Evolution of Cooperation with Peer Punishment under Prospect Theory2019

    • Author(s)
      Uchida Satoshi、Yamamoto Hitoshi、Okada Isamu、Sasaki Tatsuya
    • Journal Title

      Games

      Volume: 10(1) Issue: 1 Pages: 11-11

    • DOI

      10.3390/g10010011

    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
    • Peer Reviewed / Open Access
  • [Journal Article] 規範エコシステムアプローチによる規範と協力の共進化メカニズム2019

    • Author(s)
      山本仁志
    • Journal Title

      人工知能学会誌

      Volume: 4(2) Pages: 160-167

    • NAID

      130007917552

    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
  • [Journal Article] Social Simulation Analysis Toward a Cooperative Society2018

    • Author(s)
      山本仁志
    • Journal Title

      Journal of The Society of Instrument and Control Engineers

      Volume: 57 Issue: 6 Pages: 438-443

    • DOI

      10.11499/sicejl.57.438

    • NAID

      130007398803

    • ISSN
      0453-4662, 1883-8170
    • Year and Date
      2018-06-10
    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
    • Open Access
  • [Journal Article] Effect of direct reciprocity and network structure on continuing prosperity of social networking services2018

    • Author(s)
      Osaka Kengo、Toriumi Fujio、Sugawara Toshihauru
    • Journal Title

      Computational Social Networks

      Volume: 4 Issue: 1 Pages: 273-290

    • DOI

      10.1186/s40649-017-0038-2

    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report 2017 Annual Research Report
    • Peer Reviewed / Open Access
  • [Journal Article] A solution of private assessment in indirect reciprocity using solitary observation2018

    • Author(s)
      Okada I, Sasaki T, Nakai Y
    • Journal Title

      Journal of Theoretical Biology

      Volume: 455 Pages: 7-15

    • DOI

      10.1016/j.jtbi.2018.06.018

    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
    • Peer Reviewed / Open Access
  • [Journal Article] Experimental evidence of selective inattention of reputation-based cooperation2018

    • Author(s)
      Okada I, Yamamoto Y, Sato Y, Uchida S, Sasaki T
    • Journal Title

      Scientific Reports

      Volume: 8 Issue: 1

    • DOI

      10.1038/s41598-018-33147-x

    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
    • Peer Reviewed / Open Access
  • [Journal Article] News audience fragmentation in the Japanese Twittersphere2018

    • Author(s)
      Kobayashi, T., Ogawa, Y., Suzuki, T. and Yamamoto, H.
    • Journal Title

      Asian Journal of Communication

      Volume: 28 Issue: 3 Pages: 1-17

    • DOI

      10.1080/01292986.2018.1458326

    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
    • Peer Reviewed / Open Access / Int'l Joint Research
  • [Journal Article] Effects of beliefs about sanctions on promoting cooperation in a public goods game2018

    • Author(s)
      Yamamoto Hitoshi、Suzuki Takahisa
    • Journal Title

      Palgrave Communications

      Volume: 4 Issue: 1

    • DOI

      10.1057/s41599-018-0203-8

    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
    • Peer Reviewed / Open Access
  • [Journal Article] A Theoretical Approach to Norm Ecosystems: Two Adaptive Architectures of Indirect Reciprocity Show Different Paths to the Evolution of Cooperation2018

    • Author(s)
      Uchida Satoshi、Yamamoto Hitoshi、Okada Isamu、Sasaki Tatsuya
    • Journal Title

      Frontiers in Physics

      Volume: 6

    • DOI

      10.3389/fphy.2018.00014

    • Related Report
      2017 Annual Research Report
    • Peer Reviewed / Open Access / Int'l Joint Research
  • [Journal Article] Behavioral uncertainty and the dynamics of traders' confidence in their price forecasts2018

    • Author(s)
      Hanaki, N., Akiyama, E., and R. Ishikawa
    • Journal Title

      Journal of Economic Dynamics & Control

      Volume: 88 Pages: 121-136

    • DOI

      10.1016/j.jedc.2018.01.020

    • Related Report
      2017 Annual Research Report
    • Peer Reviewed / Open Access / Int'l Joint Research
  • [Journal Article] Effects of different ways of incentivizing price forecasts on market dynamics and individual decisions in asset market experiments2018

    • Author(s)
      Hanaki, N., Akiyama, E., and R. Ishikawa
    • Journal Title

      Journal of Economic Dynamics & Control

      Volume: 88 Pages: 51-69

    • DOI

      10.1016/j.jedc.2018.01.018

    • Related Report
      2017 Annual Research Report
    • Peer Reviewed / Open Access / Int'l Joint Research
  • [Journal Article] Tolerant indirect reciprocity can boost social welfare through solidarity with unconditional cooperators in private monitoring2017

    • Author(s)
      Okada Isamu、Sasaki Tatsuya、Nakai Yutaka
    • Journal Title

      Scientific Reports

      Volume: 7 Issue: 1 Pages: 1-11

    • DOI

      10.1038/s41598-017-09935-2

    • Related Report
      2017 Annual Research Report
    • Peer Reviewed / Open Access / Int'l Joint Research
  • [Journal Article] Exploring an Effective Incentive System on a Groupware2016

    • Author(s)
      Toriumi, F., Yamamoto, H., & Okada, I.
    • Journal Title

      Journal of Artificial Societies and Social Simulation

      Volume: 19(4) Issue: 4

    • DOI

      10.18564/jasss.3166

    • Related Report
      2016 Annual Research Report
    • Peer Reviewed / Open Access
  • [Journal Article] Cooperation-dominant Situations in SNS-norms Game on Complex and Facebook Networks2016

    • Author(s)
      Yuki Hirahara, Fujio Toriumi and Toshiharu Sugawara
    • Journal Title

      New Generation Computing

      Volume: 34-3 Issue: 3 Pages: 273-289

    • DOI

      10.1007/s00354-016-0305-z

    • NAID

      130005122682

    • Related Report
      2016 Annual Research Report
    • Peer Reviewed / Acknowledgement Compliant
  • [Presentation] Experimental evidence on incentive mechanisms2019

    • Author(s)
      Eizo Akiyama
    • Organizer
      Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences
    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
    • Int'l Joint Research / Invited
  • [Presentation] 返報と恩送りに公正世界信念が与える影響の検討2019

    • Author(s)
      梅谷凌平、山本仁志、後藤晶、岡田勇
    • Organizer
      社会情報システム学研究会第25回シンポジウム
    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
  • [Presentation] An analysis of social dilemma in the moral AI society2019

    • Author(s)
      Yamamoto, H.
    • Organizer
      52nd Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences
    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
    • Int'l Joint Research
  • [Presentation] Evolutionary Learning Model of Social Networking Services with Diminishing Marginal Utility2018

    • Author(s)
      Yutaro Miura, Fujio Toriumi, Toshiharu Sugawara
    • Organizer
      9th International Workshop on Modeling Social Media, WWW'18 Companion Proceedings of the The Web Conference 2018
    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
    • Int'l Joint Research
  • [Presentation] Flat Bubbles in Long Horizon Experiments: Results from Two Market Institutions2018

    • Author(s)
      秋山英三
    • Organizer
      第22回実験社会科学カンファレンス
    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
  • [Presentation] A questionnaire method of class evaluation using AHP with a ternary graph2018

    • Author(s)
      Oyamaguchi N, Tajima H, Okada I
    • Organizer
      KES-IDT
    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
  • [Presentation] Interface Transition of Webpages for International Communication2018

    • Author(s)
      Matsuyama H, Miyazaki M, Okada I, Ehara T, Miyazaki DL, Yokokawa S, Miyazawa S
    • Organizer
      The 21st World Multi-Conference on Systemics, Cybernetics and Informatics
    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
  • [Presentation] A comparative experiment on the first-order information an the second-order information in indirect reciprocity2018

    • Author(s)
      Okada I, Yamamoto H, Sato Y, Uchida S, Sasaki T
    • Organizer
      30th annual meeting of the Human Behavior and Evolution Society
    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
  • [Presentation] Theoretical proofs of evolutionary stabilities in indirect reciprocity of private assessment2018

    • Author(s)
      Okada I, Sasaki T, Nakai Y
    • Organizer
      2018 Annual Meeting of the Society for Mathematical Biology & the Japanese Society for Mathematical Biology
    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
  • [Presentation] Evolution of Image-scoring in indirect reciprosity2018

    • Author(s)
      Uchida S, Okada I, Yamamoto H, Sasaki T
    • Organizer
      17th Asia-Pacific conferences on <<Fundamental Problems of Opto- and Microelectronics >>
    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
  • [Presentation] 間接互恵における評判情報の参照戦略の分析2018

    • Author(s)
      岡田勇、山本仁志、佐藤克己、内田智士、佐々木達矢
    • Organizer
      日本社会心理学会第59回大会
    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
  • [Presentation] 学生の価値観を反映させた授業評価アンケートの提案2018

    • Author(s)
      大山口菜都美、田島博之、岡田勇
    • Organizer
      SSOR2018
    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
  • [Presentation] ゲーム理論による「恩送り」の解析2018

    • Author(s)
      内田智士、山本仁志、岡田勇
    • Organizer
      平成30年電気学会電子・情報・システム部門大会
    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
  • [Presentation] 間接互恵による協力の進化において公的評価と私的評価の違いが系の挙動に与える影響2018

    • Author(s)
      岡田勇
    • Organizer
      第15回生物数学の理論とその応用
    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
  • [Presentation] 三角図法による評価記述んへの重みづけの可視化法2018

    • Author(s)
      大山口菜都美、田島博之、岡田勇
    • Organizer
      日本オペレーションズリサーチ学会2018年秋期研究発表会
    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
  • [Presentation] エコシステムアプローチによる自発的参加あり繰返し囚人のジレンマの研究2018

    • Author(s)
      山本仁志、岡田勇、田口拓哉、武藤正義
    • Organizer
      第15回ネットワーク生態学シンポジウム
    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
  • [Presentation] An agent-based approach to a norm ecosystem: Exploring indispensable norms for promoting and maintaining cooperation2018

    • Author(s)
      Yamamoto, H., Okada, I., Uchida, S. & Sasaki, T.
    • Organizer
      Social Simulation 2018
    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
    • Int'l Joint Research
  • [Presentation] An Laboratory Experiment on Social Dilemmas - The Effect of 2nd Order Punishment/Sanction2018

    • Author(s)
      Akiyama, E. (with T. Nishikawa, I. Okada, F. Toriumi, and H. Yamamoto)
    • Organizer
      Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences
    • Related Report
      2017 Annual Research Report
    • Int'l Joint Research / Invited
  • [Presentation] Social Simulation on Social Dilemmas, Computational Social Science Meets Social Dilemmas: Integrating Simulations, Experiments, and Big Data Analyses2018

    • Author(s)
      Yamamoto, H
    • Organizer
      HICSS2018
    • Related Report
      2017 Annual Research Report
    • Int'l Joint Research
  • [Presentation] ソーシャルメディアにおける二次報酬可視化の効果2018

    • Author(s)
      鳥海 不二夫,山本 仁志,岡田 勇
    • Organizer
      第15回社会システム部会&第59回システム工学部会 合同研究会
    • Related Report
      2017 Annual Research Report
  • [Presentation] Effect of Network Structure for Meta-Sanctions Game2017

    • Author(s)
      Fujio Toriumi, Isamu Okada, Hitoshi Yamamoto
    • Organizer
      The 2017 International Symposium on Nonlinear Theory and its Applications
    • Related Report
      2017 Annual Research Report
    • Int'l Joint Research
  • [Presentation] Expectation for responses encourages social media participation: simulation study2017

    • Author(s)
      Fujio Toriumi, Isamu Okada, Hitoshi Yamamoto
    • Organizer
      Social Simulation Conference 2017
    • Related Report
      2017 Annual Research Report
    • Int'l Joint Research
  • [Presentation] The Effect of Second-order Reward and Punishment in Public goods Game - An Experiment2017

    • Author(s)
      Eizo Akiyaam, Isamu Okada, Fujio Toriumi, Hitoshi Yamamoto
    • Organizer
      International Conference on Social Dilemmas 2017
    • Related Report
      2017 Annual Research Report
    • Int'l Joint Research
  • [Presentation] Effects of eliciting long-run price forecasts on market dynamics in asset market experiments2017

    • Author(s)
      Akiyama, E. (with Hanaki, H. and Ishikwawa, R.)
    • Organizer
      BEAM Kyoto International Conference
    • Related Report
      2017 Annual Research Report
    • Int'l Joint Research
  • [Presentation] Effects of eliciting long-run price forecasts on market dynamics in asset market experiments2017

    • Author(s)
      Akiyama, E. (with Hanaki, H. and Ishikwawa, R.)
    • Organizer
      第21回実験社会科学カンファレンス
    • Related Report
      2017 Annual Research Report
  • [Presentation] he Effect of Second-order Rewards and Punishment in Public Goods Game --- An Experiment2017

    • Author(s)
      Akiyama, E. (with T. Nishikawa, I. Okada, F. Toriumi, and H. Yamamoto)
    • Organizer
      International Conference on Social Dilemmas
    • Related Report
      2017 Annual Research Report
    • Int'l Joint Research
  • [Presentation] Is an unsung hero necessary? An analysis of social norms required for the transition to cooperative societies2017

    • Author(s)
      Yamamoto, H., Okada, I., Uchida, S. & Sasaki, T
    • Organizer
      Social Simulation Conference
    • Related Report
      2017 Annual Research Report
    • Int'l Joint Research
  • [Presentation] Development of a norm ecosystem to understand different roles of social norms in indirect reciprocity2017

    • Author(s)
      Yamamoto, H., Okada, I., Uchida, S. & Sasaki, T
    • Organizer
      Mathematical Models in Ecology and Evolution
    • Related Report
      2017 Annual Research Report
    • Int'l Joint Research
  • [Presentation] Underestimating of reward and overestimating of punishment in public good game2017

    • Author(s)
      Yamamoto, H. & Suzuki, T.
    • Organizer
      17th International Conference on Social Dilemmas
    • Related Report
      2017 Annual Research Report
    • Int'l Joint Research
  • [Presentation] Justification Dilemma in private observation and its solution.2017

    • Author(s)
      Okada I, Sasaki T, Nakai Y.
    • Organizer
      17th International Conference on Social Dilemmas
    • Related Report
      2017 Annual Research Report
    • Int'l Joint Research
  • [Presentation] Costly reputation systems and the evolution of indirect reciprocity in the donation game2017

    • Author(s)
      Sasaki T, Okada I, Nakai Y.
    • Organizer
      Mathematical Models in Ecology and Evolution
    • Related Report
      2017 Annual Research Report
    • Int'l Joint Research
  • [Presentation] Staying: a new norm of indirect reciprocity with private information2017

    • Author(s)
      Okada I, Sasaki T, Nakai Y.
    • Organizer
      Social Simulation Conference 2017
    • Related Report
      2017 Annual Research Report
    • Int'l Joint Research
  • [Funded Workshop] Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, Symposium, Incentive Systems in the Moral AI Society2019

    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
  • [Funded Workshop] Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, Symposium, Computational Social Science Meets Social Dilemmas: Integrating Simulations, Experiments, and Big Data Analyses2018

    • Related Report
      2018 Annual Research Report
  • [Funded Workshop] Computational social science meets social dilemmas: Integrating simulations, experiments and big data analyses in Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences2018

    • Related Report
      2017 Annual Research Report

URL: 

Published: 2016-04-21   Modified: 2020-03-30  

Information User Guide FAQ News Terms of Use Attribution of KAKENHI

Powered by NII kakenhi