• Search Research Projects
  • Search Researchers
  • How to Use
  1. Back to previous page

Study on "Transplant" of the Constitutionalism and Its Present Actual Condition in the Central Asian Counties

Research Project

Project/Area Number 17330001
Research Category

Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (B)

Allocation TypeSingle-year Grants
Section一般
Research Field Fundamental law
Research InstitutionNagoya University

Principal Investigator

SUGIURA Kazutaka  Nagoya University, Graduate School of Law, Professor (40154463)

Co-Investigator(Kenkyū-buntansha) OHE Taiichiro  Shizuoka University, Law School, Professor (00097221)
KOMORIDA Akio  University of Tokyo, Institute of Social Science, Professor (30103906)
OHKOHCHI Minori  Niigata University, Institute of Humanities, Social Science and Education, Associate Professor (20345838)
Project Period (FY) 2005 – 2007
Project Status Completed (Fiscal Year 2007)
Budget Amount *help
¥8,280,000 (Direct Cost: ¥7,800,000、Indirect Cost: ¥480,000)
Fiscal Year 2007: ¥2,080,000 (Direct Cost: ¥1,600,000、Indirect Cost: ¥480,000)
Fiscal Year 2006: ¥2,600,000 (Direct Cost: ¥2,600,000)
Fiscal Year 2005: ¥3,600,000 (Direct Cost: ¥3,600,000)
KeywordsBasic Jurisprudence / Central Asia / Constitutional Court / Constitutional Council / Constitutionalism / Human Rights / Legal Culture / Transplant of Law
Research Abstract

This research was aimed at clarifying the problems and the significance today of the attempt to "transplant" constitutionalism in order to implement "market economy" "democracy" and "human rights" in Central Asian counties, particularly Uzbekistan, Kazakhstan, and Kyrgyzstan-the farmer republics of the USSR-by analyzing the system of judicial review and its actual operations in these countries. The research was based on the premise that "market economy", "democracy" and "human rights", which have been perceived as universal values since the end of the Cold War, are three interrelated factors. From a comparative perspective, the Russian Constitutional Court judgments related to the issue of constitutionalism, particularly regarding the principles of separation of powers (including the relationship between the federal government and the local autonomous entities), economic freedoms, political and personality rights and freedoms (including the right to participate in political activities) … More will also be examined.
As a result, in the cases of Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan, since the authoritarian political system putting the President in the center of all powers is incompatible with these constitutionalist attempts, "transplantation" of constitutionalism and its localization are faced by difficulties and apparently need much more time to complete. In short, it becomes near that the issue of making"transplanted" constitutionalism take mot in these two counties is closely connected to the question of reforming the authoritarian political system. Then in the case of the Kyrgyz Republic, there is no stability in the political system. As indicated by the fact that there are arguments for abandonment of the Constitutional Court which used to be very active in protecting individual rights, "transplantation" of constitutionalism is also having difficulties in taking root there. Much time is apparently needed before this may happen.
For more details please refer to the report on the research outcomes Less

Report

(4 results)
  • 2007 Annual Research Report   Final Research Report Summary
  • 2006 Annual Research Report
  • 2005 Annual Research Report
  • Research Products

    (52 results)

All 2008 2007 2006 2005

All Journal Article (36 results) Presentation (8 results) Book (8 results)

  • [Journal Article] 中央アジア諸国における裁判の独立の実態とその基本的特徴-ウズベキスタンおよびカザフスタンを例として2007

    • Author(s)
      杉浦一孝
    • Journal Title

      社会体制と法 8号

      Pages: 26-47

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] 全一の作品としての『法の精神』-法律家の読み方2007

    • Author(s)
      大江泰一郎
    • Journal Title

      静岡大学・法政研究 11巻1=2=3=4号

      Pages: 123-183

    • NAID

      110007054953

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] ロシアにおける裁判の独立-裁判官自治と裁判官の身分保障の視角から2007

    • Author(s)
      小森田秋夫
    • Journal Title

      社会体制と法 8号

      Pages: 2-25

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] Emergency constitution2007

    • Author(s)
      大河内美紀
    • Journal Title

      新潟大学・法政理論 39巻4号

      Pages: 603-630

    • NAID

      110009004113

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] The True State of the Judicial Independence and the Basic Features in the Cent alAsian Countries : Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan2007

    • Author(s)
      SUGIURA, Kazutaka
    • Journal Title

      Sotietal System and Law No.8

      Pages: 26-47

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] Spirit of Law as a Total Production2007

    • Author(s)
      OHE, Taiichiro
    • Journal Title

      Shizuoka University ; Legal and Political Studies 11, 1-2-3-4

      Pages: 123-183

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] Formation of the Modern Western Law : Coupling of Sovereignty and Property Right and its Positivization2007

    • Author(s)
      OHE, Taiichiro
    • Journal Title

      Y. Kurumizawa(ed.), Explicatio and Kritik of the Fundamental Conceptions of Law, Waseda Univ. 21th century COE

      Pages: 46-71

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] Designing Constitutional Review System in the Post-Soviet and East European Countries2007

    • Author(s)
      KOMORIDA, Akio
    • Journal Title

      The Reference No.654

      Pages: 79-113

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] Judicial Independence in Russia : from the View Point of Self-Government and Guarantee of Status of Judges2007

    • Author(s)
      KOMORIDA, Akio
    • Journal Title

      Societal System and Law No.8

      Pages: 2-25

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] Emergency constitution2007

    • Author(s)
      OHKOHCHI, Minori
    • Journal Title

      Niigata University, Journal of Law and Politics Vol.39, No.4

      Pages: 603-630

    • NAID

      110009004113

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] The Constitution guaranteed by Judicial review2007

    • Author(s)
      OHKOHCHI, Minori
    • Journal Title

      HASEBE(ed.), The Constitution 6 : The Constitution and Time, Iwanami-shoten, Tokyo

      Pages: 163-190

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] 中央アジア諸国における裁判の独立の実態とその基本的特徴2007

    • Author(s)
      杉浦 一孝
    • Journal Title

      社会体制と法 第8号

      Pages: 26-47

    • Related Report
      2007 Annual Research Report
  • [Journal Article] ロシアにおける裁判の独立2007

    • Author(s)
      小森田 秋夫
    • Journal Title

      社会体制と法 第8号

      Pages: 2-25

    • Related Report
      2007 Annual Research Report
  • [Journal Article] Emergency constitution2007

    • Author(s)
      大河内 美紀
    • Journal Title

      法政理論 39巻4号

      Pages: 603-630

    • NAID

      110009004113

    • Related Report
      2007 Annual Research Report
  • [Journal Article] ウズベキスタンにおける司法改革2007

    • Author(s)
      杉浦一孝
    • Journal Title

      杉浦一孝編「アジア法整備支援-体制移行国に対する法整備支援のパラダイム構築-」(2001年度〜2005年度・科学研究費補助金(特定領域研究))(研究成果報告書)『法整備支援と司法改革』 第7巻

      Pages: 171-204

    • Related Report
      2006 Annual Research Report
  • [Journal Article] 全一の作品としての『法の精神』-法律家の読み方2007

    • Author(s)
      大江泰一郎
    • Journal Title

      静岡大学・法政研究 第11巻第1=2=3=4号

      Pages: 123-183

    • NAID

      110007054953

    • Related Report
      2006 Annual Research Report
  • [Journal Article] ロシア連邦における移動の自由と憲法裁判所2006

    • Author(s)
      杉浦一孝
    • Journal Title

      名古屋大学・法政論集 213号

      Pages: 395-421

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] キルギス共和国における憲法改正の動向2006

    • Author(s)
      大河内美紀
    • Journal Title

      ユーラシア研究 35号

      Pages: 71-73

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] マイノリティ問題の一局面-カリフォルニア州憲法修正提案二〇九号をめぐる議論を素材に2006

    • Author(s)
      大河内美紀
    • Journal Title

      名古屋大学・法政論集 213号

      Pages: 293-334

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] Right to Freedom of Movement and the Constitutional Court in the Russian Federation2006

    • Author(s)
      SUGIURA, Kazutaka
    • Journal Title

      Nagoya University, Journal of Law Politics No.213

      Pages: 395-421

    • NAID

      110006140822

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] How was Constitutional Treaty for Europe discussed in Poland?2006

    • Author(s)
      KOMORIDA, Akio
    • Journal Title

      HABA Kumiko, KOMORIDA Akio, TANAKA Soko(ed.), European Enlargement to the East, Iwanami-shoten, Tokyo

      Pages: 152-174

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] Constitutional Reform on the Kyrgyz Republic2006

    • Author(s)
      OHKOHCHI, Minori
    • Journal Title

      Eurasian Studies No.38

      Pages: 71-73

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] A Mirror for Minority problems : in case of Proposition 209 in California2006

    • Author(s)
      OHKOHCHI, Minori
    • Journal Title

      Nagoya University ; Journal of Law Politics No.213

      Pages: 293-334

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] 欧州憲法条約はどう語られたか--ポーランドの場合2006

    • Author(s)
      小森田秋夫
    • Journal Title

      ヨーロッパの東方拡大(羽場久美子・小森田秋夫・田中素香編)(岩波書店)

      Pages: 152-174

    • Related Report
      2006 Annual Research Report
  • [Journal Article] キルギス共和国における憲法改正の動向2006

    • Author(s)
      大河内美紀
    • Journal Title

      ユーラシア研究 第35号

      Pages: 71-73

    • Related Report
      2006 Annual Research Report
  • [Journal Article] ロシア連邦における移動の自由と憲法裁判所2006

    • Author(s)
      杉浦 一孝
    • Journal Title

      名古屋大学・法政論集 第211号

      Pages: 35-62

    • Related Report
      2005 Annual Research Report
  • [Journal Article] 翻訳・キルギス共和国憲法裁判所に関する法律2006

    • Author(s)
      大河内美紀
    • Journal Title

      報告書『体制移行国における憲法適合性審査機関の役割』(名古屋大学法政国際教育協力研究センター他)

      Pages: 195-204

    • Related Report
      2005 Annual Research Report
  • [Journal Article] 翻訳・キルギス共和国における憲法裁判手続に関する法律2006

    • Author(s)
      大河内美紀
    • Journal Title

      報告書『体制移行国における憲法適合性審査機関の役割』(名古屋大学法政国際教育協力研究センター他)

      Pages: 205-222

    • Related Report
      2005 Annual Research Report
  • [Journal Article] 比較法文化論における政治権力・所有秩序カップリング2005

    • Author(s)
      大江泰一郎
    • Journal Title

      静岡大学・法政研究 9巻4号

      Pages: 1-60

    • NAID

      110001189244

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] 旧ソ連・東欧諸国における違憲審査制の制度設計2005

    • Author(s)
      小森田秋夫
    • Journal Title

      レファレンス 654号

      Pages: 79-113

    • NAID

      40006859485

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] A Climate of the Russian Constitution and Peculiarity of a Debate on a Revision of the Constitution of Japan2005

    • Author(s)
      SUGIURA, Kazutaka
    • Journal Title

      Japan Association for Studies of Constitutional Law(ed), The Problem of a Revision of the Constitution of Japan, Nihon-Hyoronsha, Tokyo

      Pages: 286-289

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] The Coupling of Political Power and Ownership in the Study of Comparative Culturology of Law2005

    • Author(s)
      OHE, Taiichiro
    • Journal Title

      Shizuoka University, Legal and Political Studies Vol.9, No.4

      Pages: 1-60

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] Structural Change of Criminal Justice in Russia2005

    • Author(s)
      KOMORIDA, Akio
    • Journal Title

      HIROWATARI Seigo, et. al.(ed.), Perspective of Democratic Jurisprudence and Criminal Law Science, Nihon-Hyoronsha, Tokyo

      Pages: 463-487

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] Poland and EU2005

    • Author(s)
      KOMORIDA, Akio
    • Journal Title

      MORII Yuichi(ed.), Enlarged Europe in the International Relations, Shinzansha, Tokyo

      Pages: 251-283

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Journal Article] 旧ソ連・東欧諸国における違憲審査制の制度設計2005

    • Author(s)
      小森田秋夫
    • Journal Title

      レファレンス 第654号

      Pages: 79-113

    • NAID

      40006859485

    • Related Report
      2005 Annual Research Report
  • [Journal Article] ロシアにおける刑事司法の構造転換-被疑者・被告人の権利の視点から2005

    • Author(s)
      小森田秋夫
    • Journal Title

      小田中聰樹先生古稀記念論文集 民主主義法学・刑事法学の展望・下巻(広渡清吾他編)(日本評論社)

      Pages: 463-487

    • Related Report
      2005 Annual Research Report
  • [Presentation] アソシエーション法の比較研究-<国家-社会-個人>をつなぐ法のすがた-ポーランド2007

    • Author(s)
      小森田秋夫
    • Organizer
      比較法学会
    • Place of Presentation
      北海道大学
    • Year and Date
      2007-06-03
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Presentation] Comparative Study on Association Law-Poland2007

    • Author(s)
      KOMORIDA, Akio
    • Organizer
      Japan Society of Comparative Law
    • Place of Presentation
      Hokkaido University
    • Year and Date
      2007-06-03
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Presentation] 現存(旧)社会主義国における「裁判統制制度」の改革についての比較検討・ロシア2007

    • Author(s)
      杉浦一孝
    • Organizer
      比較法学会
    • Place of Presentation
      北海道大学
    • Year and Date
      2007-06-02
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Annual Research Report 2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Presentation] キルギス共和国における違憲審査制の動揺2007

    • Author(s)
      大河内美紀
    • Organizer
      比較法学会
    • Place of Presentation
      北海道大学
    • Year and Date
      2007-06-02
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Presentation] Comparative Studies on the "System of Control over Justice" Reforms in Existing and Former Socialist Countries : Russian Federation2007

    • Author(s)
      SUGIURA, Kazutaka
    • Organizer
      Japan Society of Comparative Law
    • Place of Presentation
      Hokkaido University
    • Year and Date
      2007-06-02
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Presentation] The Change of Judicial Review System in Kyrgyzstan2007

    • Author(s)
      OHKOHCHI, Minori
    • Organizer
      Japan Society of Comparative Law
    • Place of Presentation
      Hokkaido University
    • Year and Date
      2007-06-02
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Presentation] 体制移行国における裁判の独立の実態-中央アジア諸国とロシア連邦2006

    • Author(s)
      杉浦一孝
    • Organizer
      「社会体制と法」研究会
    • Place of Presentation
      立命館大学
    • Year and Date
      2006-06-02
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Presentation] The Actual Situation of Judirial Independence in Countries in System Transition : the Central Asian Countries and Russian Fedemtion2006

    • Author(s)
      SUGIURA, Kazutaka
    • Organizer
      Association for "Societal System and Law" Studies
    • Place of Presentation
      Ritumeikan Univerity
    • Year and Date
      2006-06-02
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Book] 体制転換と法-ポーランドの道の検証2008

    • Author(s)
      小森田秋夫
    • Total Pages
      432
    • Publisher
      有信堂
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Annual Research Report 2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Book] Systemic Transformation and Law - Examining the Polish Way2008

    • Author(s)
      KOMORIDA, AIo
    • Total Pages
      432
    • Publisher
      Yushindo, Tokyo
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Book] 楜澤能生編『法の基本概念のexplicatioとKritik』2007

    • Author(s)
      大江泰一郎
    • Publisher
      早稲田大学21世紀COE「企業法制と法創造」総合研究所「基本的概念のクリティーク」研究会
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Book] 長谷部恭男編『岩波講座憲法6 憲法と時間』2007

    • Author(s)
      大河内美紀
    • Publisher
      岩波書店
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Book] 羽場久美子・小森田秋夫・田中素香(編)『ヨーロッパの東方拡大』2006

    • Author(s)
      小森田秋夫
    • Publisher
      岩波書店
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Book] 法律時報増刊・全国憲法研究会編『憲法改正問題』2005

    • Author(s)
      杉浦一孝
    • Publisher
      ロシアの憲法動向と日本の改憲論の特殊性
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Book] 広渡清吾他編『小田中聰樹先生古稀記念論文集 民主主義法学・刑事法学の展望・下巻』2005

    • Author(s)
      小森田秋夫
    • Publisher
      日本評論社
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary
  • [Book] 森井裕一編『国際関係の中の拡大EU』2005

    • Author(s)
      小森田秋夫
    • Publisher
      信山社
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Related Report
      2007 Final Research Report Summary

URL: 

Published: 2005-04-01   Modified: 2016-04-21  

Information User Guide FAQ News Terms of Use Attribution of KAKENHI

Powered by NII kakenhi