• Search Research Projects
  • Search Researchers
  • How to Use
  1. Back to project page

2007 Fiscal Year Final Research Report Summary

Significance and Limit of the Progressive View of History and Possibility of an Alternative View: Reviewing the Controversy between the Ancients and the Moderns

Research Project

Project/Area Number 18320007
Research Category

Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (B)

Allocation TypeSingle-year Grants
Section一般
Research Field Philosophy/Ethics
Research InstitutionNiigata University

Principal Investigator

KURIHARA Takashi  Niigata University, Institute of Humanities, Social Sciences and Education, Professor (30170088)

Co-Investigator(Kenkyū-buntansha) KATO Hisatake  Tottori University of Environmental Studies, Graduate School of Environment Informations, Professor (10011305)
ZAKOTA Yutaka  Tohoku University, Graduate School of Arts and Letters, Professor (20125579)
ISAKA Seishi  Kanagawa University, Faculty of Foreign Languages, Professor (30175195)
YAMAUCHI Shiro  Keio University, Fuculty of Letters, Professor (30210321)
SATO Toru  Tohoku University, Graduate School of International Cultural Studies, Associate Professor (60222014)
Project Period (FY) 2006 – 2007
KeywordsControversy between the Ancients and the Moderns / Progressive View of History / Philosophy of Histoty / The Aesthetical Revolution / Transcendental Idealism / German Romanticism / Narratology / New Mythology
Research Abstract

1. As results of our collaborative study, we have found that the European contrast between the Ancient and the Modern was similar to that between the South and the North, or between totality and subjectivity, and that the characters of Modern Pictures can be discovered already in the Flemmish School in the 15th century, before Descartes. These themes were discussed in the articles by .KURIHARA, ISAKA and OTABE in Study of Hegelian Philosophy, vol. 12 and 13.
2. The progressive view of history was not an thought that simply honored the modern progress, but that was motivated by the hopes of overcoming the modern. Another expression of such hopes was the romanticism. These were themes of OTABE, KURIHARA and ISAKA in Studies on the German Romantic School (edited by ISAKA).
3. In the Hegelian thesis of the End of Art, a contrast between the Ancient and the Modern means that between art and philosophy. Hegel argued that in the modern atomic society, in which art was just an hobby, philosophy should get back the self-cognition of spirit and overcome the modern. These themes were discussed by KURIHARA (Article "When art becomes interesting"), YAMAUCHI, SATO, KATO, OTABE, MORIMOTO, KIDO, ISAKA and ZAKOTA in When art begins, and when art ends (edited by KURIHARA).
4. According to our research (KURIHARA, ISAKA, KATO), transcendental idealism was projected as another view of history as "development of self-consciousness", against the progressive view of history as quantitative accumulation.

  • Research Products

    (54 results)

All 2008 2007 2006

All Journal Article (24 results) (of which Peer Reviewed: 3 results) Presentation (6 results) Book (24 results)

  • [Journal Article] Der Begriff des Fragments in Friedrich Schlegels Asthetik,2008

    • Author(s)
      Tanehisa Otabe
    • Journal Title

      Lothar Knatz, Nobuyuki Kobayashi und Takao Tsunekawa (Hrsg.), Leben und Geschichte. Studien zur deutschen Geistesgeschi chte des 19. und 20. Jahrhunderts

      Pages: S.57-68

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Journal Article] 有意味性の相互主観的構成について2008

    • Author(s)
      佐藤 透
    • Journal Title

      ヨーロッパ研究 7(印刷中)

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Journal Article] Conception of Fragments in Friedrich Schlegel's Aesthetics2008

    • Author(s)
      OTABE, Tanehisa
    • Journal Title

      Life and History : Study of German Intellectual History of 19th and 20th Century(in German),(Lothar Knatz, Nobuyuki Kobayashi and Takao Tsunekawa(eds.))

      Pages: 57-68

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Journal Article] On Inter-subjective Constructions of Significance2008

    • Author(s)
      SATO, Toru
    • Journal Title

      European Studies Vol.7

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Journal Article] ドゥンス・スコトゥスとイスラーム哲学-共通本性の系譜2007

    • Author(s)
      山内 志朗
    • Journal Title

      大航海 62号

      Pages: 94-103

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Journal Article] 修験道と湯殿山信仰2007

    • Author(s)
      山内 志朗
    • Journal Title

      理想 678号

      Pages: 26-36

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Journal Article] 精神現象学というゆがんだ真珠2007

    • Author(s)
      加藤 尚武
    • Journal Title

      『現代思想 7月号臨時増刊 ヘーゲル』

      Pages: 8-13

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Journal Article] 実体-主体説と実体-主語説2007

    • Author(s)
      加藤 尚武
    • Journal Title

      理想 679

      Pages: 4-14

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Journal Article] Tsuneyoshi Tsuzumi, a Pioneer in Comparative Aesthetics, and His Theory of 'Framelessness of Japanese Artistic Style': Toward Intercultural Aesthetics,2007

    • Author(s)
      Tanehisa Otabe
    • Journal Title

      International Yearbook of Aesthetics, 11

      Pages: 111-130

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Journal Article] 芸術終焉論の諸類型-ヘーゲル理解のための-座標2007

    • Author(s)
      小田部 胤久
    • Journal Title

      ヘーゲル哲学研究 13

      Pages: 173-181

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Journal Article] Wie wurden "Europa" und "Asien" in der modernen Asthetikaufgefasst? Fr. Schlegel und Kakuzo(Tenshin)Okakura,2007

    • Author(s)
      Tanehisa Otabe
    • Journal Title

      The Journal of Aesthetics and Science of Art(The Korean Society of Aesthetics and Science of Art), 26

      Pages: S.57-68

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Peer Reviewed
  • [Journal Article] 「真実の生」における人間-フィヒテ宗教論の射程2007

    • Author(s)
      座小田 豊
    • Journal Title

      フィヒテ研究 15

      Pages: 22-41

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Journal Article] Duns Scotus and Islamic Philosophy: An Genealogy of Common Nature2007

    • Author(s)
      YAMAUCHI, Shiro
    • Journal Title

      Great Voyages(Daikokai) Vol.62

      Pages: 94-103

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Journal Article] SHUGENDO and the Cult of YUDONOSAN2007

    • Author(s)
      YAMAUCHI, Shiro
    • Journal Title

      Ideal(Risou) Vol.678

      Pages: 26-36

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Journal Article] "The Phenomenology of Spirit" as the Baroque2007

    • Author(s)
      KATO, Hisatake
    • Journal Title

      Contemporary Thought(Gendai Shiro), Special Issue : Hegel

      Pages: 8-13

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Journal Article] What does "Subject" in Hegel's Thesis "Substance-Subject"?2007

    • Author(s)
      KATO, Hisatake
    • Journal Title

      Ideal(Risou) Vol.679

      Pages: 4-41

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Journal Article] Tsuneyoshi Tsuzumi, a Pioneer in Comparative Aesthetics, and His Theory of 'Framelessness of Japanese Artistic Style': Toward Intercultural Aesthetics2007

    • Author(s)
      OTABE, Tanehisa
    • Journal Title

      International Yearbook of Aesthetics Vol.11

      Pages: 111-130

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Journal Article] Several Types of the End of Art: An Axis for Understanding Hegel2007

    • Author(s)
      OTABE, Tanehisa
    • Journal Title

      Study of Hegeian Philosophy Vol.13

      Pages: 173-181

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Journal Article] How did the Modern Aesthetics grasp "Europe" and "Asia"? Fr. Schlegel and Kakuzo(Tenshin) Okakura2007

    • Author(s)
      OTABE, Tanehisa
    • Journal Title

      The Journal of Aesthetics and Science of Art(The Korean Society of Aesthetics and Science of' Art) Vol.26

      Pages: 57-68

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Journal Article] Man in "The True Life": Scope of Fichte's Philosophy of Religion2007

    • Author(s)
      ZAKOTA, Yutaka
    • Journal Title

      Fichte Study Vol.15

      Pages: 22-41

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Journal Article] 意識と無-シュルツェとドイツ観念論2006

    • Author(s)
      栗原 隆
    • Journal Title

      ヘーゲル哲学研究 12

      Pages: 124-138

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Peer Reviewed
  • [Journal Article] シェリング同一哲学とヘーゲル初期哲学体系構想の差異2006

    • Author(s)
      伊坂 青司
    • Journal Title

      ヘーゲル哲学研究 12

      Pages: 139-154

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
    • Peer Reviewed
  • [Journal Article] Consciousness and Nothing: Schulze and German Idealism2006

    • Author(s)
      KURIHA, Takashi
    • Journal Title

      Study of Hegelian Philosophy Vol.12

      Pages: 124-138

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Journal Article] Difference between Schelling's Identity-Philosophy and Hegel's Early Conception of System of Philosophy2006

    • Author(s)
      ISAKA, Seishi
    • Journal Title

      Study of Hegeian Philosophy Vol.12

      Pages: 139-154

    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Presentation] "New Mythology" and Christianity: Different Ways of Schelling and Hegel2007

    • Author(s)
      ISAKA, Seishi
    • Organizer
      Japan Hegel Society
    • Place of Presentation
      Japan Women's University
    • Year and Date
      2007-12-18
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Presentation] 『新しい神話』とキリスト教-シェリングとヘーゲルの分岐2007

    • Author(s)
      伊坂 青司
    • Organizer
      日本ヘーゲル学会
    • Place of Presentation
      日本女子大学
    • Year and Date
      2007-12-08
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Presentation] 精神現象学のホーリズム2007

    • Author(s)
      加藤 尚武
    • Organizer
      東北哲学会
    • Place of Presentation
      東北大学文学部
    • Year and Date
      2007-10-20
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Presentation] Holism in "The Phenomenology of Spirit"2007

    • Author(s)
      KATO, Hisatake
    • Organizer
      The Philosophical Society of Tohoku
    • Place of Presentation
      Tohoku University
    • Year and Date
      2007-10-20
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Presentation] 精神と世界-歴史的世界を創建する神話としての超越論的観念論2007

    • Author(s)
      栗原 隆
    • Organizer
      日本ヘーゲル学会
    • Place of Presentation
      名古屋市立大学
    • Year and Date
      2007-06-17
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Presentation] Spirit and World: Transcendental Idealism as an Myth Founding the Historical World2007

    • Author(s)
      KURIHARA, Takashi
    • Organizer
      Japan Hegel Society
    • Place of Presentation
      Nagoya University
    • Year and Date
      2007-06-17
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Book] カント哲学のアクチュアリティー-哲学の原点を求めて2008

    • Author(s)
      坂部恵・佐藤康邦(編):小田部胤久、他
    • Total Pages
      312
    • Publisher
      ナカニシヤ出版
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Book] 普遍論争、近代の源流としての2008

    • Author(s)
      山内 志朗
    • Total Pages
      480
    • Publisher
      平凡社
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Book] Actuality of Kant: Searching for the Origin of Philosophy2008

    • Author(s)
      OTABE, Tanehisa, et. al.
    • Total Pages
      312
    • Publisher
      Nakanishiya Publishing
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Book] Controversy over Universals: As an Origin of Modern Philosophy2008

    • Author(s)
      YAMAUCHI, Shiro
    • Total Pages
      480
    • Publisher
      Heibonsha
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Book] 現代カント研究10 理性への問い2007

    • Author(s)
      城戸 淳(共著)
    • Total Pages
      258
    • Publisher
      晃洋書房
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Book] ドイツ・ロマン派研究2007

    • Author(s)
      伊坂青司(編):栗原隆:小田部胤久
    • Total Pages
      574
    • Publisher
      御茶の水書房
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Book] <つまずき>のなかの哲学2007

    • Author(s)
      山内 志朗
    • Total Pages
      221
    • Publisher
      NHK出版
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Book] 芸術の始まる時、尽きる時2007

    • Author(s)
      栗原隆(編):座小田豊:伊坂青司:山内志朗:小田部胤久:城戸淳、他
    • Total Pages
      459
    • Publisher
      東北大学出版会
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Book] 哲学の歴史 7 理性の劇場2007

    • Author(s)
      加藤尚武(編):加藤尚武・小田部胤久・栗原隆・座小田豊・伊坂青司・山崎純、他
    • Total Pages
      718
    • Publisher
      中央公論社
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Book] 哲学の歴史 3 神との対話2007

    • Author(s)
      中川純男(編):山内志朗、他
    • Total Pages
      774
    • Publisher
      中央公論社
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Book] <冗長さ>が大切です2007

    • Author(s)
      山内 志朗
    • Total Pages
      152
    • Publisher
      岩波書店
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Book] Contemporary Kant Study 10: Question about Reason2007

    • Author(s)
      KIDO, Atsushi, et. al.
    • Total Pages
      258
    • Publisher
      Koyoshobo
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Book] Studies on the German Romantic School(ISAKA, Seishi(ed.))2007

    • Author(s)
      KURIHARA, Takashi, OTABE, Tanehisa, et. al.
    • Total Pages
      574
    • Publisher
      Ochanomizu-shobo
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Book] Philosophy in Baffle2007

    • Author(s)
      YAMAUCHI, Shiro
    • Total Pages
      221
    • Publisher
      NHK Publishing
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Book] When art beggins, and when art ends(KURIHARA, Takashi(ed.))2007

    • Author(s)
      ZAKOTA, Yutaka, ISAKA, Seishi, YAMAUCHI, Shiro, OTABE, Tanehisa, KIDO, Atsushi, et. al.
    • Total Pages
      459
    • Publisher
      Tohoku University Press
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Book] History of Philosophy 7: Theater of Reason(KATO, Hisatake(ed.))2007

    • Author(s)
      OTABE, Tanehisa, KURIHARA, Takashi, ZAKOTA, Yutaka, ISAKA, Seishi, YAMAZAKI, Jun, et. al.
    • Total Pages
      718
    • Publisher
      Chuokoronsha
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Book] History of Philosophy 3: Dialogue with God2007

    • Author(s)
      YAMAUCHI, Shiro, et. al.
    • Total Pages
      774
    • Publisher
      Chuokoronsha
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Book] Redundancy is Important2007

    • Author(s)
      YAMAUCHI, Shiro
    • Total Pages
      152
    • Publisher
      Iwanamishoten
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Book] 哲学の問題群-もういちど考えてみること2006

    • Author(s)
      城戸 淳(共編著)
    • Total Pages
      331
    • Publisher
      ナカニシヤ出版
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Book] 交響するロマン主義2006

    • Author(s)
      小田部 胤久(共編著)
    • Total Pages
      206
    • Publisher
      晃洋書房
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Book] 異界の交錯2006

    • Author(s)
      山内 志朗(共著)
    • Total Pages
      482
    • Publisher
      リトン
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(和文)」より
  • [Book] Problems of Philosophy: What You Think Again2006

    • Author(s)
      KIDO, Atsushi
    • Total Pages
      336
    • Publisher
      Nakanishiya Publishing
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Book] Symphonic Romanticism2006

    • Author(s)
      OTABE, Tanehisa
    • Total Pages
      206
    • Publisher
      Koyoshobo
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より
  • [Book] Crossing of the Transmundane2006

    • Author(s)
      YAMAUCHI, Shiro, et. al.
    • Total Pages
      482
    • Publisher
      Riton
    • Description
      「研究成果報告書概要(欧文)」より

URL: 

Published: 2010-02-04  

Information User Guide FAQ News Terms of Use Attribution of KAKENHI

Powered by NII kakenhi