Review ArticleDoctors’ experience of becoming patients and its influence on their medical practice: A literature review
Introduction
That doctors should always be healthy is an age-old premise in Western medicine.23,30,48,50,79,87 This idea possibly originates from a quote in the Corpus Hippocraticum (as edited in the Roman era) that ‘Doctors should look healthy’.45 A quote based on the same premise, ‘Isha no Fuyojoh’, which literally means ‘Doctors do not care about their health’ appeared in a Japanese book written in the 18th century and was coined to tease a doctor who fell sick. This quote has been widely used since then and continues to be frequently heard in Japan when doctors fall sick. Therefore, doctors have long been expected to remain healthy. Doctors also take it for granted that they would always be healthy. Ironically, many of them appear to not care about their health.15,91 Kay et al.53 reported that medical students and doctors are seldom taught how to deal with their own illnesses throughout their medical education and training. However, owing to recent concerns about the psychological, social, and physical well-being of medical students and doctors,15,55,81,93,97 the influence of the educational environment on learners’ wellness has been investigated and interventions geared toward improving students’ and doctors’ well-being have been implemented by medical schools93 and training hospitals.20,94 Therefore, it can be said that doctors, medical educators, and educational institutions have begun to seriously tackle issues related to doctors’ health and well-being.
Another well-known but contradictory idea persists that doctors should become patients at least once to be able to understand their patients.67,73 This alludes to the notion that without experiencing patienthood, doctors cannot truly understand what it means to be ill, despite seeing patients almost every day. Thus, this idea suggests that there is a disconnect between the doctor and patient until the doctor falls ill.
These themes have long garnered the interest of doctors and researchers. In his book, Sickness and Healing: An Anthropological Perspective, the American epidemiologist and anthropologist Robert Hahn points out that ‘the written accounts in the genre of doctors’ illnesses had been seen for over thirty years.40 (p. 235). In 2018, there are far more illness narratives written by doctors and researchers than in the past, along with guidelines and guidebooks for when doctors become ill. Nevertheless, as there are no literature reviews on the illness experiences of doctors and how these experiences influence doctors’ medical practice, it is difficult to determine how to further explore this topic.
We reviewed the existing literature on doctors’ illness experiences to deepen our understanding of how these experiences influence doctors’ medical practice. We also reviewed illness narratives (both articles and pathographies) by doctors and compared them with academic studies. These reviews lead us to highlighting the necessity of further research on doctors’ experiences as patients and how these experiences influence their medical practice.
Section snippets
Search strategy
We reviewed literature published until 2017 on the electronic databases Academic Search Complete, Google Scholar, PubMed, ProQuest and Ichushi-Web (an electronic database for Japanese medical journals); although owing to its own limitations, the first database, only included papers published between 1961 and 2016. The keywords used were ‘doctors become patients’ and ‘doctors as patients’ for Google Scholar and ‘doctors become patients’ and ‘physicians become patients’ for Academic Search
Results
In the first section of the results, we review the academic studies of doctors’ illness experiences. In the second section, we review the illness narratives to enrich our understanding of the academic studies. By combining a study of narratives with that of formal studies, a deeper understanding of physicians’ illness experiences is expected.
Discussion
The existing literature illustrates how doctors’ afflictions result in them changing their perspectives about themselves and others through their experiences of becoming patients. Academic literature has explored these issues qualitatively and quantitatively, not only in the field of medicine but in other fields too, such as sociology and anthropology. Doctors’ experiences as patients differ from those of the general public because they navigate between their medical selves, role reversals and
Acknowledgments
We wish to thank the graduate students and the faculty of the Medical Education Center, Kyoto University Graduate School of Medicine, for the fruitful discussions on this article. We also thank Prof. Kazuhiro Kazama, Assoc. Prof. Ayako Iwatani, Asst. Prof. Gaku Kajimaru, and their students at the Graduate School of Human and Environmental Studies, Kyoto University. They gave us substantial comments and helped us to revise the draft. My thanks also go to Assoc. Prof. Mario Ivan Lopez, Center for
Declaration of Competing Interest
The authors declare no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship or publication of this paper.
Funding
This research did not receive any grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial or non-profit sectors.
Mariko Morishita is a Ph.D. student and teaching assistant at the Medical Education Centre at the Graduate School of Medicine, Kyoto University, where she studies medical education and medical anthropology. Her research interests include doctors’ experiences with becoming patients, doctors’ wellbeing, and undergraduate primary care education.
References (98)
- et al.
Young doctors’ health-II. Health and health behaviour
Soc Sci Med
(1997) - et al.
Physician burnout is better conceptualised as depression
Lancet
(2017) - et al.
Doctors’ personal health care choices: a cross-sectional survey in a mixed public/private setting
BMC Public Health
(2008) - et al.
Mortality rates and causes among U.S. physicians
Am J Pre Med
(2000) - et al.
Comparison of delay times to hospital presentation for physicians and nonphysicians with acute myocardial infarction
Am J Cardiol
(1992) - et al.
Should physicians’ self-prescribing be restricted by law?
Lancet
(2005) - et al.
Health seeking behavior of physicians at the JOS university teaching hospital
Niger Med J
(2011) - et al.
Self-medication practices among health care professionals in a private university, Malaysia
Int Curr Pharm J
(2012) - American Medical Association. 2016. Treating self or family....
The ama code of medical ethics’ opinion on physicians treating family members
Virtual Mentor
(2012)
When clinicians become patients, treatment journeys help shape their approaches to care
Hem/Onc Today
Why physicians work when sick
Arch Intern Med
Patients’ perspectives autopathography: the patient's tale
BMJ
Exploring senior doctors’ beliefs and attitudes regarding mental illness within the medical profession: a qualitative study
BMJ Open
Self-medication among doctors and pharmacists at the Korle Bu Teaching Hospital
Qualitative data analysis for health services research: developing taxonomy, themes, and theory
Health Res. Educ. Trust
Am I cured from cancer? A physician's personal experience
Support Care Cancer
Physician do not heal thyself
Canad Fam Phys
The physician-administrator as patient: distinctive aspects of medical care
Perspect Biol Med
A study of self-care among Irish doctors
Ir Med J
Septicaemi and the doctor-patient
South African Fam Pract
Doctors’ health-seeking behaviour: a questionnaire survey
Med J Aust
Comparison of perforation risk among physicians, other medical professionals and general adults with acute appendicitis in Taiwan
Br J Surg
Physicians as patients: a comparative study of attitudes of physicians and non-physicians
Psychopathology
Self-prescription practices by Nigerian medical doctors
South African Fam Pract
“Patients, not doctors, get sick”: a study of fifteen Swedish physicians on long-term sick leave
Int J Qual Stud Health Well-Being
Doctors as patients: postal survey examining consultants and general practitioners adherence to guidelines
BMJ
Medical Anthropology
Naissance De La Clinique [The Birth of the Clinic]. Translated
What happens when doctors are patients? qualitative study of GPs
Br J Gen Pract
Junior doctors’ experiences of personal illness: a qualitative study
Med Educ
At the Will of the Body: Reflections on Illness, Reprinted
Self-doctoring: a qualitative study of physicians with cancer
J Fam Pract
Physician, heal thyself: a qualitative study of physician health behaviors
Acad Psychiatry
I would never want to have a mental health diagnosis on my record: a survey of female physicians on mental health diagnosis, treatment, and reporting
Gen Hosp Psychiatry
Qualitative research and evidence based medicine
BMJ
Quality of hospital care evaluated by Danish nurses and doctors-based on experience from their own or a close family member's hospitalization
Dan Med Bull
Sickness and healing, an anthropological perspective
Pending appendicectomy: a personal experience and review of a doctor’ s own illness
BMJ Case Rep
A postal survey of doctors’ attitudes to becoming mentally ill
Clin Med (Lond)
When a doctor becomes a patient with a mystery illness: a case report
Case Rep Med
Hippocrates zenshu, Dai-1-Kan
Hippocrates zenshu Dai-2-Kan
Hosokawa hiromichi ikoh-shu shi-shu byoja hana
[The Hosokawa Hiromichi's Posthumous works. A Patient and Flowers]
A comparison of the stages at which cancer is diagnosed in physicians and in the general population in taiwan
CMAJ
Cited by (13)
“It's all about the story”. Osteopaths' experiences of exploring menopausal symptoms: A qualitative interview study
2023, International Journal of Osteopathic MedicineLearner Experiences of Preceptor Self-Disclosure of Personal Illness in Medical Education
2024, Academic MedicineIstoria and Eureka: Valuing Story and Discovery in Research and Publication in the Human Sciences
2024, Ethics and Social WelfareThe experiences and challenges of nurses who become patients in a hospital setting: A scoping review of the literature
2024, Journal of Advanced NursingHealth Care Utilization and Self-Treatment by Primary Care Physicians and Specialist Physicians
2023, Deutsches Arzteblatt InternationalThe Utilization of Medical Services by Doctors in Outpatient Practice
2023, Deutsches Arzteblatt International
Mariko Morishita is a Ph.D. student and teaching assistant at the Medical Education Centre at the Graduate School of Medicine, Kyoto University, where she studies medical education and medical anthropology. Her research interests include doctors’ experiences with becoming patients, doctors’ wellbeing, and undergraduate primary care education.
Junko Iida is a professor of anthropology at the Comprehensive Education Centre (Faculty of Health and Welfare), Kawasaki University of Medical Welfare, Japan. Her research interests include Thai traditional medicine, local healing practices in northern Thailand, palliative care in Japan, and anthropology education for (future) health professionals.
Hiroshi Nishigori is a professor in the Centre for Medical Education, Graduate School of Medicine, Nagoya University and is the Visiting Project Leader professor in the Medical Education Centre at the Graduate School of Medicine, Kyoto University. His research interests include medical professionalism, medical education within the humanities, and virtue ethics in medical education.